Review, by James Tapia: "...there is no reason to rush out and buy this title, and even die-hard Sonic fans will tire of it quickly." [Score: 6.5 out of 10]
Review, by Rachel Lewis: "Most players will feel disappointed by Sonic Shuffle, especially if they expect a game of the same quality as other Sonic ones." [Grade: C]
Review, by zerothreat: "...not only is the game lacking in innovation, but it's dragged way, way down by uneven and confusing mini games, far too many load-time interruptions and horrible, sophomoric music." [Score: 5.5 out of 10]
Review, by Anthony Chau: "Anyone who gets Sonic Shuffle will pull their hair out in agonizing frustration..." [Score: 4.7 out of 10] (November 15, 2000)